Heat Pump vs Air Conditioner: Which HVAC System is Right for You?

Heat Pump vs Air Conditioner: Which HVAC System is Right for You?

    The Difference Between a Heat Pump and Air Conditioner

    When it comes to heating and cooling your home, understanding the difference between a heat pump and an air conditioner is key to making the right choice. Surprisingly, some homeowners already have a heat pump system without even realizing it! This makes sense, given that these systems look almost identical on the outside. But knowing what sets them apart can help you make an informed decision for your home’s comfort needs.

    In Cooling Mode, Heat Pumps and Air Conditioners are Equal

    Both heat pumps and air conditioners excel at keeping your home cool during the warmer months. They work by circulating refrigerant between your indoor and outdoor units. As the refrigerant moves through the system, it absorbs heat from inside your home and releases it outside, delivering cool air indoors and lowering the temperature and humidity. A heat pump cools just as well as an air conditioner because it IS an air conditioner.

    Heating: The Heat Pump Advantage

    The main difference with a heat pump is that it can reverse its operation to also heat your home during the winter. It still uses the same refrigeration process as in the summer, but now it absorbs heat from outdoors and transfers (or pumps) it indoors. While an air conditioner steps aside when the temperature drops—handing the job over to a fossil fuel furnace or boiler—a heat pump continues working year-round, pulling double duty to deliver both cool air and warm air into your home.

    The Key Difference: The Reversing Valve

    So, how does a heat pump manage to heat your home? Heat pumps work due to one crucial component: the reversing valve. This piece of technology changes the direction of the refrigerant flow, allowing the system to pull heat from the outside air and bring it inside. Yes, even in cold weather, there’s plenty of heat energy in the outdoor air for the refrigerant to absorb! The compressor then compresses the refrigerant, tripling the pressure and making it hot enough to heat your home.

    Trane Heat Pump Reversing Valve
    Trane Heat Pump Reversing Valve

    Air Source Heat Pumps vs. Other Types

    When people talk about heat pumps, they’re usually referring to air-source heat pumps—the type that draws heat from the outdoor air. While there are also water-source heat pumps, like geothermal systems that pull heat from the ground, we’ll focus on the air-source variety here, as they’re the most common. For more info on geothermal heat pumps, click here.

    Heat pump vs Air Conditioner FAQs

    Heat pumps are more efficient than straight electric heaters down to about -15 degrees Fahrenheit. So yes, they can work in cold climates. However, as the outdoor temperature drops, a heat pump produces less heat while your home needs more. So, below about 30 degrees Fahrenheit, they may depend on a little help from a backup heat source to keep your home at peak comfort and efficiency.

    The outdoor unit is about $700 - $1,000 more for a heat pump. But both units require combination with an indoor unit to move air through your home. Typically, we combine central air conditioners with gas furnaces and heat pumps with air handlers. Air handlers are much cheaper than gas furnaces, ultimately making a full heat pump system a bit cheaper than a full gas furnace - A/C system.

    Air conditioners last longer than heat pumps because they get half the runtime.

    In cooling mode, air conditioners and heat pumps are equals. If you've read or heard that heat pumps are more energy efficient, that conversation is likely referring to the comparison between electric resistance heaters.

    Yes, we can replace your A/C with a heat pump. You can even keep your fossil fuel furnace for backup on very cold nights. You can also switch to an air handler (electric furnace) in tandem with your heat pump if your home electric service is large enough.

    Heat Pump vs Air Conditioner Cost Comparison

    When shopping for heat pumps and air conditioning units, cost is often a primary consideration.

    Heat pumps have a higher upfront cost (typically between $700 to $1,000) compared to air conditioners. The additional technology required for the heating function causes this price increase.

    However, this higher initial investment when comparing heat pumps to air conditioners is offset by a few things...

    Firstly, there are the long-term potential energy savings, especially if natural gas is not available in your neighborhood. Since these energy savings are only in heat mode, this cost comparison should be made between heat pumps and whatever heat type you currently have (be it natural gas, propane, fuel oil, or only electric). We cover this topic more in another article here.

    Second, heat pumps can eliminate the need for a fossil fuel heating system, such as a furnace. Having a heat pump gives you the option of going all-electric with just an air handler indoors. This removes the hassle of dealing with propane or oil deliveries and ugly fuel tanks. No fossil fuel means no chimneys, eliminating a source of carbon monoxide in your home.

    (you could also have a hybrid system with furnace + heat pump as we discuss here)

    Because air handlers are much simpler (just a blower, electric heater, and coil), they are less expensive to install than a furnace. This is assuming you have enough electric supply available. Retrofitting from a furnace to an air handler will likely require running a larger electric supply from the breaker panel.

    Third and finally, by eliminating your fossil-fuel heating system, you’ll typically reduce maintenance costs.

    In general, a heat pump + air handler combination is less complicated, easier to maintain, and more reliable than an A/C + gas furnace combination. Many factors go into this, including the brand of unit and quality of install.

    For more detailed info on installation costs, check out our pages on air conditioner pricing and heat pump pricing.

    Trane Heat Pump and Air Conditioner Outdoor Units
    Heat Pump and Air Conditioner Outdoor Units

    Air Conditioner and Heat Pump Installation Differences

    Installation of an A/C and heat pump are virtually identical. The primary installation difference is that we must elevate the heat pump above the expected snow level so that it can properly defrost and drain in the winter. This is commonly done by hanging it from the wall with a bracket or by raising it from the A/C pad with bricks or snow legs.

    The other difference is a couple of extra thermostat wires to the outdoor unit to control the reversing valve and to signal to the stat that the heat pump is in defrost mode. While most thermostats can control a heat pump system, if you’re upgrading from an air conditioner, chances are there are not enough control wires in the wall and you’ll need to pull a new thermostat wire.

    Comparing A/C and Heat Pump Energy Efficiency

    In the conversation of energy efficiency, it’s a common belief that heat pumps are more energy efficient than air conditioners. However, the reality is that both systems operate at the same level of cooling efficiency, depending on the specific SEER2 rating of the unit you choose. For example, Trane makes their model XV18 in both an air conditioner and a heat pump, and both achieve a SEER2 rating of 18.0, meaning they offer identical cooling efficiency.

    There is one key difference in measuring heat pump and air conditioner efficiency though. In addition to measuring cooling efficiency with SEER2, heat pumps rate their efficiency in heating mode with HSPF2. Air conditioning systems only have SEER2 as their energy efficiency rating, but heat pumps have both SEER2 and HSPF2 ratings. The SEER2 rating stands for Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio (cooling efficiency), while the HSPF2 rating stands for Heating Seasonal Performance Factor (heating efficiency). These ratings allow you to compare individual heat pumps and air conditioners, estimating the energy savings when you upgrade to a high-efficiency model.

    In regions like Ohio, where we experience both summer and winter fully (though relatively mild), heat pump systems provide phenomenal year-round efficiency. But modern air conditioners can give you equally great energy efficiency in the summer.

    Lifespan Comparison of Air Conditioner and Heat Pump

    When you’re deciding between an air conditioner or a heat pump, the expected lifespan of each can play a big role in your decision.

    While versatile, heat pumps tend to have a shorter lifespan than air conditioners. Why? Because a heat pump works overtime, putting in year-round work to keep your home at the right temperature. This constant operation means more wear and tear, which can lead to more frequent maintenance and a shorter overall lifespan.

    Air conditioners often outlast heat pumps simply because they’re only used during the warmer months. With less strain on the system, A/Cs tend to need fewer repairs and offer a longer service life.

    Whatever you choose, regular maintenance is the key to extending the life of your HVAC system, ensuring it runs at peak efficiency for as long as possible, and preventing costly repairs down the line.

    Heat Pump HSPF and SEER energy efficiency ratings
    Heat Pump HSPF and SEER energy efficiency ratings

    Can I Replace My A/C with a Heat Pump?

    When homeowners are looking for a new cooling system, they often assume they can’t get a heat pump because they currently have an A/C. We’re here to debunk that myth.

    Simply put: Yes, you can replace your A/C with a heat pump. There are very few instances where it’s impossible to replace an air conditioner unit with a heat pump unit.

    Still, in some situations, it might not be the best option. It all comes down to what options are available in your neighborhood.

    If you currently heat your home with fuel oil or electric resistance heaters in a mild climate, moving to a heat pump is a no-brainer. The energy savings will quickly give you a return on your investment. If you have an existing propane furnace, a hybrid setup with a heat pump and a propane furnace makes a lot of sense. Below about 0 degrees Fahrenheit, propane becomes cheaper to heat with, and the warmer air coming from the vents in the dead of winter can feel more comfortable and cozy.

    Switching from natural gas is a different story. You can certainly replace your A/C with a heat pump and keep your gas furnace as a hybrid HVAC system. As the temperature drops, gas furnaces quickly become the most economical choice below about 50 degrees Fahrenheit. With the heat pump only running about 10% of the heating season, it may not be worth the added installation cost. Surprisingly, heat pumps produce about twice the carbon footprint compared to natural gas furnaces! If you have natural gas, we certainly don’t recommend replacing it with an all-electric heat pump system.

    Of course, this advice is all based on our service area in Ohio, its moderate climate, fuel costs, and coal-based electricity supply.

    Should I Choose a Heat Pump or Air Conditioner?

    Making the final decision between a heat pump and air conditioner can feel like a big decision. It really depends on a few key factors based on your specific home’s setup. Let’s break it down to help you figure out which option might be best for you.

    Climate Considerations

    If you live in an extremely cold climate with nighttime temperatures routinely hitting -10 degrees Fahrenheit, a heat pump might not be the best fit. When outdoor temperatures drop below about 30 degrees Fahrenheit, heat pumps can’t provide enough heat on their own and need a little extra boost from electric strip heat. Below -15 degrees Fahrenheit, they produce very little heat and the energy efficiency drops below that of electric strip heat.

    With a hybrid setup, you would turn the heat pump off and switch to fossil fuel. This means that in very cold climates, the heat pump would only get runtime in the Spring and Fall and may not be worth the investment. In our service area in Ohio, we only get a few nights per year below 0 degrees Fahrenheit, making a heat pump a great choice.

    Electrical System Limitations

    Your home’s electrical system is also an important factor to consider. Heat pumps don’t require any more power than standard air conditioners. However, the average backup heater in an air handler needs a 90 amp circuit. If you’re replacing a propane or oil furnace with an air handler, you will only have a 15 amp circuit. This means, at minimum, you will need an electrician to run a new circuit from the panel.

    Worst case, they’ll need to upsize the electric service from the pole and replace your entire panel. This may seem extreme, but it’s typically not a deal breaker as electricians do service upgrades all the time at an extra upfront cost.

    Existing Heating Systems

    If you’ve recently installed a high-efficiency furnace, swapping it out for an all-electric heat pump system might not make financial sense. Your furnace likely still has a lot of life left. Adding a heat pump to your existing fossil fuel furnace to make a hybrid system can be a great option. But if your furnace is natural gas, you shouldn’t expect to save any extra money on your utility bills in heating mode.

    Making the Final Decision

    In the end, choosing between air conditioners and heat pump systems is all about understanding your home’s specific needs, your climate, and your long-term goals. For cooling, air conditioners and heat pumps perform identically. Heat pumps provide outstanding heating performance, rivaled only by natural gas furnaces. Modern heat pumps produce three to four watts of heat for every watt of electricity they consume. Hopefully, you’ve found this info helpful in your research.

    Ultimately, having an HVAC expert come out and assess your home is the only true way to know what the perfect system is for you. If you’re ready to take the next step, our comfort specialists can perform a professional evaluation of your home and help you make the best choice for year-round comfort.

    Contact Us

    • Please let us know any other information about your request
    David Watkins

    David Watkins

    As a third generation HVAC professional, David Watkins grew up around all things heating and air conditioning. He is an expert in airflow and duct design and he leverages his math and science background to lead an HVAC team well-known for their technical capabilities.

    Other Recent Blog Posts

    Heat Pump Unit Covered in Ice
    Service and Repair

    Heat Pump Defrost Cycle: Understanding the Process and Trane’s Innovative Approach

    Heat pumps are just like air conditioners except they have a "reverse gear." By changing direction of the refrigerant flow, they can not only ...
    Read More
    Air Conditioner Tax Credit Rebate
    HVAC Replacement

    What HVAC System Qualifies for Tax Credit 2024?

    Homeowners in Ohio have a fantastic opportunity to save money on new HVAC systems with federal tax credits available throughout 2024. If you're considering ...
    Read More
    Air Conditioner vs Heat Pump
    HVAC Replacement

    Heat Pump vs Air Conditioner: Which HVAC System is Right for You?

    The Difference Between a Heat Pump and Air Conditioner When it comes to heating and cooling your home, understanding the difference between a heat ...
    Read More
    Trane XV20i and Trane XV18 Air Conditioner
    HVAC Replacement

    Difference Between Trane XV20i and XV18 Heat Pump and Air Conditioner

    When looking for the best A/C or heat pump for your forever home, the Trane XV20i and XV18 models stand out as the top ...
    Read More
    Trane HVAC Heat Pump Indoor Outdoor Unit Combo
    HVAC Replacement

    Heat Pump A/C Combo Setups: Cool Summers, Warm Winters

    Choosing a new heating and cooling system can be confusing with all the different options for heat pumps, air conditioners, furnaces, and air handlers. ...
    Read More
    Furnace Carbon Monoxide Cause Inspection
    Indoor Air Quality

    What Causes Carbon Monoxide in Homes

    Understanding Carbon Monoxide Carbon monoxide (CO) is a colorless, odorless, tasteless gas that can be deadly in your home. It is often referred to ...
    Read More
    Woman with CO Poisoning Symptoms Headache
    Indoor Air Quality

    Recognizing the Signs and Symptoms of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning

    What is Carbon Monoxide? Carbon monoxide gas (CO) is a deadly, invisible threat. Because carbon monoxide is a colorless, odorless, and tasteless gas, it ...
    Read More
    Watkins Trane 2023 SOAR Award for Dayton Cincinnati
    Watkins News

    Watkins Heating and Cooling Wins the 2023 – 2024 Trane SOAR Award

    We're thrilled to announce that Watkins has been honored with this year's prestigious Trane SOAR Award for the Dayton and Cincinnati, Ohio area. This ...
    Read More
    Air Conditioning Lightning Strike
    Service and Repair

    Understanding Air Conditioner Lightning Strikes

    If you live in the Miami Valley, you’re more than familiar with the regular spring and summer thunderstorms! They can be pleasant to fall ...
    Read More
    Loveserves board visiting a pastor in Guatemala City
    Missions and Ministry

    LoveServes Guatemala 2024

    Last week, my wife and I visited the beautiful country of Guatemala to visit Saq B'e, one of our LoveServes partners. Our purpose was ...
    Read More
    APCO UV Light Installation in HVAC System
    Indoor Air Quality

    How to Prevent A/C Evaporator Coil From Leaking Freon

    Refrigerant, commonly referred to as Freon, is essential to the functioning of your air conditioning system. Your air conditioner pumps refrigerant around, absorbs heat ...
    Read More
    Watkins HVAC Tech Check AC with Leak Detector
    Service and Repair

    What Causes Refrigerant Leaks in Air Conditioners

    If your air conditioning system leaks refrigerant, it can lead to major problems such as lower energy efficiency, higher bills, and a shorter lifespan ...
    Read More
    Watkins HVAC technician checking AC refrigerant Freon levels
    Service and Repair

    What Refrigerant is Used in Home A/C Units?

    Refrigerant is the lifeblood of your home’s air conditioning system. It circulates between your A/C's indoor evaporator coil and the outdoor condenser coil, transferring ...
    Read More
    Cutaway view of Trane heat pump air conditioner showing spine fin condenser coil
    HVAC Replacement

    Trane Aluminum Spine Fin Coils – Pros and Cons

    Trane All-Aluminum Spine Fin™ Coils The Trane Spine Fin™ condenser coil is a distinctive and patented technology used by Trane in their air conditioning ...
    Read More
    Watkins HVAC tech stands with new Trane XV20i heat pump after replacement job
    HVAC Replacement

    Can I Replace Just My Air Conditioner Without Replacing My Furnace?

    Can I Replace the AC Unit Without Replacing the Furnace? It's one of the most common questions we get in the HVAC world and ...
    Read More
    SEER2 EnergyGuide Air Conditioner Rating Label
    HVAC Replacement

    What the New SEER2 Standards Mean for Air Conditioners and Heat Pumps In 2024

    What is SEER? What on Earth is SEER2, how is it different than the regular old SEER rating, and what does it mean for ...
    Read More
    Gas furnace heat exchanger safety check
    HVAC Replacement

    Cracked Heat Exchangers

    Scam alert! Each heating season, numerous Dayton heating contractors are tempted to lie about cracked heat exchangers in an attempt to sell more furnaces. ...
    Read More
    Danfoss thermal expansion valve TXV
    Service and Repair

    Understanding the TXV

    The HVAC TXV (Thermal Expansion Valve). How it works and why it fails. When it comes to a heating & cooling system, there are ...
    Read More
    Watkins AC Repair Man
    Indoor Air Quality

    Top 10 Most Common HVAC Issues and How to Prevent Them

    A well-functioning HVAC system is essential for maintaining a comfortable and healthy living environment in your home. However, HVAC systems are complex and can ...
    Read More
    Replace install hvac heat pump air conditioner
    HVAC Replacement

    Discovering Heat Pumps: Your Guide to Energy-Efficient Home Comfort

    Switching to a heat pump in Ohio's climate Heat pumps are becoming increasingly popular as an energy-efficient and environmentally friendly heating and cooling solution ...
    Read More
    Trane Air Conditioner WeatherGuard Cover
    Service and Repair

    Air Conditioner Covers

    Protective Covers for Air Conditioners: Do You Really Need Them? Autumn's arrival often raises concerns about outdoor air conditioning units. Falling leaves, snow, and ...
    Read More
    Rafa and John building a wall
    Missions and Ministry

    Teaching, Building, and Changing Lives in the Dominican Republic

    We just got back from another great mission trip to the Dominican Republic. Over the past few years, we have been working with a ...
    Read More
    Home Heating and Cooling Rebates
    HVAC Replacement

    Utility Heating & Cooling Rebates Explained

    In the Miami Valley there are three utility companies offering rebates. The purpose of the rebates is to drive higher efficiency across the region ...
    Read More
    AC Manufacturing Warehouse
    HVAC Replacement

    Factory Warranties

    For last few years, the heating industry has waged a “warranty war” with the various furnace brands offering longer and longer parts warranties. We ...
    Read More
    Watkins Employee Does Maintenance on HVAC System
    Indoor Air Quality

    Home Humidity 101

    We are only halfway through December and we've already installed a full winter's budget of Aprilaire humidifiers. It looks like static and dryness have ...
    Read More
    Watkins Heating and Cooling help St. Vincent
    Missions and Ministry

    Introduction to Our Work in St. Vincent

    Randy and I left chilly Ohio on January 4th for a three-month missions trip to the island of St. Vincent. Our son-in-law, Daniel, attended ...
    Read More
    Air Conditioner Leaking Water on Floor
    Service and Repair

    Air conditioner maintenance | Water leaks

    I have been a service technician with Watkins Heating & Cooling for over 10 years now. Every spring I have a routine to prepare ...
    Read More
    air conditioner coil cleaning
    Service and Repair

    Air Conditioner Coil Cleaning

    Dirty A/C coils cause overheating A few days ago my wife and I were relaxing in our living room after the kids had gone ...
    Read More
    solar powered hvac company
    Watkins News

    Zoning for Solar Energy

    When it comes to zoning laws, perception is nine tenths of the law (how's that for a mixed metaphor)? You may own your home, ...
    Read More
    Watkinsheating Hiring !
    Watkins News

    We’re Hiring!

    The huge referrals from our wonderful customers have us a little overwhelmed. We need to add more seasoned service and installation techs to our ...
    Read More
    Mitsubishi Zoned Comfort ductless mini-split heat pump
    HVAC Replacement

    It Is Cold Upstairs! Comfort Tips for a Two-Story Home.

    I live in a two-story house built in the sixties. Like many homes in the Miami Valley, temperatures can vary widely from upstairs to ...
    Read More
    Watkins Tech Explaining New Trane Air Conditioner XR16 Install to Customer
    Service and Repair

    REAL Service Technicians

    I believe I can speak for most service technicians when I say we all love to talk shop. If you were to listen in ...
    Read More
    Dominican Missions
    Missions and Ministry

    Watkins’ Mission to Transform Lives in the Dominican Republic

    For years our family has been personally involved in overseas missions work. Our business is seasonal which makes it easy to get away in ...
    Read More
    Technician working on a high efficiency furnace
    Service and Repair

    Top 5 Reasons for a Furnace Tune-up

    Homeowners frequently ask, “Why does my furnace need a tune-up every year?” As our techs will tell you, a neglected furnace will eventually leave ...
    Read More
    Best HVAC Repair Google Search in Tab
    Service and Repair

    How Do You choose an HVAC Contractor?

    Baby it's warm inside! It is 6:30 PM, and you have just returned home from a grueling day at work. You are ready to ...
    Read More
    heat pump thermal balance point
    HVAC Replacement

    Heat pump operation 102

    In my last post, Heat Pump Operation 101, I explained how the efficiency and capacity of a heat pump vary with the weather. How ...
    Read More
    Watkins Service Technician Heat Pump Maintenance Tune-Up
    HVAC Replacement

    Heat pump operation 101

    Many homes in the Miami Valley are heated and cooled by Heat Pumps, but few homeowners understand how they work. Hopefully I can dispel ...
    Read More
    Honeywell Carbon Monoxide Alarm
    Service and Repair

    Carbon Monoxide Safety

    With the time-change, local news stations always recommend changing the batteries in your smoke detector. Furnace guys would extend that reminder to carbon monoxide ...
    Read More
    furnace_filters
    Indoor Air Quality

    6 Furnace Air Filter Tips

    A question asked quite often by my customers is, “How often should I change my furnace filter?” Another popular question is, “Why do you ...
    Read More
    gas pilot light before and after cleaning
    Service and Repair

    Routine furnace maintenance saves money

    I’m sitting here in my two-seat, diesel powered office thinking about the season. There are reminders everywhere; trees without leaves, frost covered grass, Christmas ...
    Read More
    Trane ECM motor module
    Service and Repair

    Committed to Your Comfort: Trane Heat Pump Repairs Done Right

    This morning, we encountered a malfunctioning ECM fan control module on an older Trane heat pump. These modules are crucial for your unit’s performance, ...
    Read More
    Hope House Rescue Mission Dayton Logo
    Missions and Ministry

    Watkins Brings Comfort through Hope House Rescue Mission

    Reprint of press release from PRWeb. Watkins Heating and Cooling today announced a two-year commitment to provide free furnace and air conditioner maintenance to ...
    Read More
    Heating Check
    Service and Repair

    Goodbye Freon!

    I am sitting in a class today getting some continuing education for my Ohio master license. Today’s course is a review on R-410a (Puron), ...
    Read More